Best Hickory Flooring for 2018 with Reviews and Comparisons

Hickory wood floors are really good looking, they are durable, and they even smell quite nice too.

If you are on the hunt for the best hickory flooring that your money can buy, you definitely want to stick around. We want to take a look at the very best options right now.

Comparison Chart

First Pick
HARMONICS SAVANNAH HICKORY SH801S 12 planks...
Runner Up
TrafficMASTER Handscraped Saratoga Hickory 7 mm...
Third Choice
COREtec Plus Red River Hickory Engineered Vinyl...
Sample of US Floors COREtec Plus 5" Engineered...
Cali Bamboo - Cali Vinyl Plus Cork-Backed Vinyl...
HARMONICS SAVANNAH HICKORY SH801S 12 planks...
TrafficMASTER Handscraped Saratoga Hickory 7 mm...
COREtec Plus Red River Hickory Engineered Vinyl...
Sample of US Floors COREtec Plus 5" Engineered...
Cali Bamboo - Cali Vinyl Plus Cork-Backed Vinyl...
Editor's Rating
Prime Available?
-
-
-
-
First Pick
HARMONICS SAVANNAH HICKORY SH801S 12 planks...
HARMONICS SAVANNAH HICKORY SH801S 12 planks...
Editor's Rating
Prime Available?
Runner Up
TrafficMASTER Handscraped Saratoga Hickory 7 mm...
TrafficMASTER Handscraped Saratoga Hickory 7 mm...
Editor's Rating
Prime Available?
-
Third Choice
COREtec Plus Red River Hickory Engineered Vinyl...
COREtec Plus Red River Hickory Engineered Vinyl...
Editor's Rating
Prime Available?
-
Sample of US Floors COREtec Plus 5" Engineered...
Sample of US Floors COREtec Plus 5" Engineered...
Editor's Rating
Prime Available?
-
Cali Bamboo - Cali Vinyl Plus Cork-Backed Vinyl...
Cali Bamboo - Cali Vinyl Plus Cork-Backed Vinyl...
Editor's Rating
Prime Available?
-

Our Hickory Flooring Reviews and Comparisons 

1. ​Harmonics Savannah Hickory SH801S 12 planks

HARMONICS SAVANNAH HICKORY SH801S 12 planks...

This is a fairly inexpensive option to go with when you consider how good looking and durable HARMONICS SAVANNAH HICKORY planks are. It’s not the cheapest option out there, but it is also one of the better ones.

HARMONICS SAVANNAH HICKORY SH801S 12 planks...

Features:

  • Great Design
  • Very Durable
  • Easy Installation

Product Highlights

With each package, you get 13 planks of HARMONICS SAVANNAH HICKORY flooring. Each plank is 5 1/4" wide x 47 1/4" long x 5/16" thick and enough to cover about 20 square feet. You also get the underlayment pads to help make installation much easier.

To be quite honest, besides saying that this wood is already finished and that it looks really nice, there is not much else to say about it. It’s quite durable, it has a good grain, a natural wood look, and is easy to install.

What's to like about Harmonics Savannah Hickory SH801S 12 planks

We like how HARMONICS SAVANNAH HICKORY flooring is very tough and durable, how it comes with the underlayment pads, and how it is quite easy to install. The price is also pretty good.

What's not to like about Harmonics Savannah Hickory SH801S 12 planks

The only bad part about this flooring, as far as we can tell, is that you only get enough to cover 20 square feet, which is really not that much. 

PROS

  • check

    Tough and durable

  • check

    Scratch resistant

  • check
    Finished
  • check
     Easy to install
  • check
    Good price
  • check
    Comes with the underlayment pads

CONS

  • Not very much included in a single package

2. ​TrafficMASTER Handscraped Saratoga Hickory

TrafficMASTER Handscraped Saratoga Hickory 7 mm...

This is a very beautiful and durable hickory flooring option to go with. It is quite expensive, but in our opinion, it is worth the price.

TrafficMASTER Handscraped Saratoga Hickory 7 mm...

Features:

  • Great Design
  • Very Durable
  • Easy Installation

Product Highlights

TrafficMASTER Handscraped Saratoga Hickory is a nice option to go with thanks to the fact that it is hand scraped for a high-quality finish. This is real hickory wood that is coated with a laminate finish for a super high level of durability.

In a single case, you get enough to cover roughly 24 square feet of floor space, which is not bad. The dark wood grain and the beautiful swirls work really well with both old fashion and modern homes.

What's to like about ​TrafficMASTER Handscraped Saratoga Hickory

TrafficMASTER Handscraped Saratoga Hickory is a nice option to go with because first off, it looks absolutely beautiful. It looks like it came right out of the forest, but comes complete with a laminate finish that will keep it in top condition for years to come. Besides being durable and good looking, there is not much to be said here. Installation is also not too difficult.

What's not to like about ​TrafficMASTER Handscraped Saratoga Hickory

The only bad thing about TrafficMASTER Handscraped Saratoga Hickory is that it is quite expensive. You could probably find the same thing at a big box store for a fraction of the price.

PROS

  • check
    Hard and Durable
  • check
    Comes with a laminate finish
  • check
    Very Scratch Resistant
  • check
    Fairly Easy Installation
  • check
    Covers a full 24 square feet

CONS

  • Expensive
  • times-circle
    Not 100% Pure Wood

3. ​COREtec Plus Red River Hickory Engineered Vinyl

COREtec Plus Red River Hickory Engineered Vinyl...

Ok, so this is a really nice looking and super durable option to go with. COREtec Plus Red River Hickory Engineered Vinyl comes in at a reasonable price, but to be clear, this flooring is made to look like hickory, but is actually vinyl.

COREtec Plus Red River Hickory Engineered Vinyl...

Features:

  • Great Design
  • Durable
  • Fairly Easy Installation

Product Highlights

One of the cool parts here is that this flooring can be installed to float, or in other words, simply lock the panels together with the click lock feature each panel comes with. Being so easy to install is a feature that most people should be able to appreciate.

Moreover, while COREtec Plus Red River Hickory Engineered Vinyl is not real hickory, it is very durable and long lasting. It looks just like hickory, but because it is vinyl, it is much more scratch resistant than real hickory wood. This flooring is 100% waterproof and comes with a lifetime warranty, both important features.

What's to like about ​COREtec Plus Red River Hickory Engineered Vinyl

For one, we like how COREtec Plus Red River Hickory Engineered Vinyl is extremely durable and long lasting. It is highly scratch resistant as vinyl tends to be. Moreover, the free-floating installation is extremely convenient. Being waterproof is a big bonus too, and of course you can’t look down your nose at a full lifetime warranty either.

What's not to like about ​COREtec Plus Red River Hickory Engineered Vinyl

We honestly do not like how this is not real hickory. Yes, it looks like hickory and is actually more durable, but we know that it is not real, and knowing is more than enough.

PROS

  • check
    Very durable
  • check
    Scratch resistant
  • check
    100% waterproof
  • check
    Easy free floating installation
  • check
    Good price
  • check
    Lifetime warranty

CONS

  • Not actually real hickory

4. ​Red River Hickory Engineered Vinyl Planks

Sample of US Floors COREtec Plus 5' Engineered...

While Red River Hickory Engineered Vinyl Planks are actually very expensive, they are also of a very high quality. In our opinion, if it were not for the high price, this option would probably be our number one pick.

Sample of US Floors COREtec Plus 5' Engineered...

Features:

  • Great Durability
  • Amazing Design
  • Easy Installation

Product Highlights

First off, here you get planks that are 5 by 48 inches with a thickness of 8 mm. To be clear, this is in the style of red river hickory, but it is in fact vinyl.

That being said, this particular vinyl is built to be tough and long lasting. For one, it is totally waterproof and can even be put in areas that regularly get wet. It won’t absorb water, it won’t expand, and it won’t contract either. 

The bottom features a thin layer of cork for a softer walking experience, plus it does a good job with heat retention.

This flooring is inert and stable, and therefore will keep its shape perfectly. The micro-beveled edges make installation a breeze, and the lifetime warranty is a good indication of the manufacturer’s confidence in their product. 

What's to like about ​Red River Hickory Engineered Vinyl Planks

There are quite a few good aspects here. We like how Red River Hickory Engineered Vinyl Planks look like the real thing, hickory, but are actually much tougher and more durable. Being 100% waterproof and resistant to changing shape is a big deal, plus we do also really like the layer of cork featured on the bottom. All in all, this is an excellent option to keep in mind.

What's not to like about ​Red River Hickory Engineered Vinyl Planks

First off, it is not actually real hickory, which might be seen as a bad thing. Next, Red River Hickory Engineered Vinyl Planks are fairly expensive, which we are not exactly thrilled about.

PROS

  • check
    Extremely durable
  • check
    Waterproof
  • check
    Won’t expand or contract
  • check
    Stays fairly warm
  • check
    Looks very nice
  • check
    Lifetime warranty

CONS

  • Expensive
  • times-circle
    Faux hickory

5. ​Cali Bamboo Vinyl Aged Hickory Flooring

Cali Bamboo - Cali Vinyl Plus Cork-Backed Vinyl...

This is a really inexpensive option to go with, one that looks like real hickory flooring, but is actually a mixture of stamped bamboo and vinyl. It looks real, it feels real, it’s durable, and it costs a fraction of the price of the real thing.

Cali Bamboo - Cali Vinyl Plus Cork-Backed Vinyl...

Features:

  • Great Design
  • Easy Installation
  • Great Price

Product Highlights

Cali Bamboo Vinyl Aged Hickory Flooring features an easy click-lock installation. You can do it all on your own and you don’t even need any glue, nails, or tools.

The HiFi imaging used here captures the real and authentic look of hickory, but it is actually a bamboo vinyl plank. In other words, it looks just as nice as hickory, but is actually much tougher and way more scratch resistant. 

The cork underlay is very nice because it makes for a soft walking surface and it is good for heat retention too. Cali Bamboo Vinyl Aged Hickory Flooring is 100% waterproof, making it great for areas that tend to get wet.

What's to like about ​Cali Bamboo Vinyl Aged Hickory Flooring

We like how Cali Bamboo Vinyl Aged Hickory Flooring is so easy to install. It is also very durable, waterproof, and long lasting. It looks real and is quite tough, which is really all we are looking for. This flooring doesn’t even cost very much, an added bonus.

What's not to like about ​Cali Bamboo Vinyl Aged Hickory Flooring

If we were really picky, we would not greatly appreciate how this is more or less a knock-off hickory.

PROS

  • check
    Looks like the real thing
  • check
    Very durable
  • check
    Waterproof
  • check
    Very easy to install
  • check
    Good price

CONS

  • Not actually real hickory

FINAL VERDICT

The moderate price, the high quality, high level of durability, and the beautiful look of HARMONICS SAVANNAH HICKORY SH801S flooring makes it our number one choice. However, both TrafficMASTER Handscraped Saratoga Hickory and COREtec Plus Red River Hickory Engineered Vinyl are both close runners-up.

Find out some fun facts about Hickory flooring.



Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.